All Cleaned Out - Elliott Smith Song Discussion

63

By composed

Elliott Smith and the Big Nothing
Amazon Price: $6.22
List Price: $15.99
New Moon
Amazon Price: $12.91
List Price: $18.98
Elliott Smith 'All Cleaned Out'
Elliott Smith 'All Cleaned Out'

All Cleaned Out is another classic Elliott Smith song.  As with all art of this high quality, I am open to interpretations.  In fact, I love hearing them.

To me, All Cleaned Out is about someone who is wholly unsure of himself. Someone who can keep it together for a while, but eventually screws things up...

and then becomes a disappearing man
after a little while

The key part of the song, though, for me is right here...

you toss the empty beer
not really as composed as you appear
an icicle inside
wearing clothes that clash
wondering is this treasure or is this trash
still trying to decide

We all try to put on fronts and act as if we have it together.  But, in reality, many of us have no idea who we are.  For some, life is one ongoing identity crisis ('clothes that clash).  And we constantly wonder if the moment or the future is 'treasure' or 'trash.'  Life is a process and as Bruce Springsteen once said, "There's no resolution to the human experience."  But we are taught to act 'composed,' but as Elliott often wrote we're not always as composed as we appear.

We go into our corners, our own little worlds and we don't want anyone else around.  We shut out the world.  We shut out people who love us.  Human contact and the process of really getting to know others, ourselves, and our place in the world drains us... we become All Cleaned Out.

This sort of crisis of not having the energy to deal with the crap that life and society throws at us comes up often in Elliott's music.  More than not having the energy, though, is the notion that why should we have to deal with the absurdity of the world and most facets of social life in the first place?  I think Elliott gets at just that in Can't Make a Sound when he notes: "The monologue means nothing to me..."

Thoughts?


Comments

Cris A profile image

Cris A Level 2 Commenter 3 years ago

Basing on the title, I think I got the analogy wrong for I initially thought "cleaned out" pertains to ridding of baggages and being open. But i see your point. Nice song, btw. thanks for sharing :D

composed profile image

composed Hub Author 3 years ago

Not a problem. I love sharing my obsessions. THat whole record - New Moon - as is the case with his others is nothing short of amazing. Easily the most underrated and unknown great singer-songwriter of all time.

Cris A profile image

Cris A Level 2 Commenter 3 years ago

I'm glad you brought him to light as honestly this is the first time I've heard of him. So thanks, again for sharing :D

composed profile image

composed Hub Author 3 years ago

yeah, I had not heard of Elliott until after his death. such is life.

Cris A profile image

Cris A Level 2 Commenter 3 years ago

oh well, life's a you know what sometimes :(

aintsoobvious profile image

aintsoobvious 2 years ago

.. Any lover of elliott's music is a friend to me so i ask what i ask with the greatest respect.. Why ignore the direct address to his mother which begins the song? "here comes your pride and joy, the comic little drunk you call your boy..." i think that is a step back for elliott, remembering the possibilities, forks in the road he turned away from - another recurrent theme in a lot of his material.. Also, the not wanting anyone around, dreamless sleep motifs and the phrase "all cleaned out" seem to suggest withdrawl from substances which may have made life easier for a time.. I don't know.. What needs to be remembered about New Moon is that none of these songs were finished - Elliott wouldn't have wanted them in the public domain in the state they were in and hence many of the lyrics can come off as misleading because they weren't the finished article - it's why i love the album as much as i do i think.. much love to you brother/sister.. either/or!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working